Libreoffice Design Session: Shapes

The Libreoffice UX team presents two proposals on how to access shapes from the sidebar, with the goal to unify the look and feel of Libreoffice tools and to get more space for additional categories of shapes.

Libreoffice Draw was treated somewhat novercally in last time. But we didn’t forget it and started to pimp its look and feel. This design session was about moving the stencils from the shapes toolbar into the sidebar. And of course not only Libreoffice Draw benefits from this effort.

Topic: Shapes Sidebar Tab

Big Tickets/Feature Requests:

Issue/Problem

  • Complex toolbars with menu buttons have in general the issue of missing direct access
  • Addition of shapes are possible not from the sidebar
  • Shapes toolbar has a limited amount of shapes (e.g. predefined shapes for BPMN)
  • No means of easily adding new shapes to toolbar
  • Shapes toolbar is hidden by default in Writer and Calc
  • Not easy to see the full range of shapes at once

Screenshots of current UI

Figure

Figure1. Current toolbar in Libreoffice Draw.

Features/Functional Requirements

  • List of recently used shapes
  • Search through shapes by name
  • Have icon view and detail view with names
  • Provide more shapes by default
  • User can extend the current list of shapes

New design/Mockup

Option 1 (Accordion)

Figure 1

Figure 2: Accordion style.

  • Sections for every shape category
  • Expanded by default but collapsible
  • User-defined section for more shapes that can be loaded from repository via add button (button right hand at the section header); file with single shape or compressed list of files
  • Load single files into user-defined section and provide drag ‘n drop to sort items into one of the existing categories
  • Compressed list of items to create new category filled with those items
  • Search (alternative view on right hand) works as a filter and reduces the content; only those accordion sections are shown that contains of icon named according the search
  • Right hand view shows the viewing option to list items with names (detailed view instead of icon view)
  • Recently used items is limited for two rows in default size

We discussed another flavor with fixed section above the user-defined categories.

20150327_Shapes-2

Figure 3: Accordion with programmably viable style.

  • Contains a default shapes section that provides access to LO hardcoded shapes and more section to additional shapes
  • Search and recently used items are available only in the more section

Option 2 (Linked lists)

Figure 3

Figure 4: Linked lists like folder/file.

  • Similar to the gallery section; upper list contains of shape categories, below the items are listed
  • This style has the same add, search, and recently used functionality as the accordion style
  • Consumes less space
  • Usability drawback of separating controls for one action

Conclusion

We present two and a half mockups on how to integrate shapes into the sidebar. By doing so we not only want to unify the look and feel of Libreoffice tools. We also want to get more space in order to add further categories of shapes. For instance there is an open source repository available from DIA http://dia-installer.de/shapes/index.html.en. And we want to ask you which of the following categories should be added by default into Libreoffice. Nevertheless, the idea is to implement a mechanism to download and install shapes on demand like templates. But that requires coding and takes some time.

Which category of shapes should be added by default?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Of course we are interested in your opinion on how to integrate the shapes into the sidebar. What is your preference? Do you have a use case that we didn’t cover yet?